Winning Strategies in Real Estate

Busting the Myth About a Housing Affordability Crisis


It seems you can’t find a headline with the term “housing affordability” without the word “crisis” attached to it. That’s because some only consider the fact that residential real estate prices have continued to appreciate. However, we must realize it’s not just the price of a home that matters, but the price relative to a purchaser’s buying power.

Homes, in most cases, are purchased with a mortgage. The current mortgage rate is a major component of the affordability equation. Mortgage rates have fallen by over a full percentage point since December 2018. Another major piece of the affordability equation is a buyer’s income. The median family income has risen by 3.5% over the last year.

Let’s look at three different reports issued recently that reveal how homes are very affordable in comparison to historic numbers, and how they have become even more affordable over the past several months.

1. National Association of Realtors’ (NAR) Housing Affordability Index:

Here is a graph showing the index going all the way back to 1990. The higher the column, the more affordable homes are:Busting the Myth About a Housing Affordability Crisis | MyKCMWe can see that homes are less affordable today (the green bar) than they were during the housing crash (the red bars). This was when distressed properties like foreclosures and short sales saturated the market and sold for massive discounts. However, homes are more affordable today than at any time from 1990 to 2008.

NAR’s report on the index also shows that the percentage of a family’s income needed for a mortgage payment (16.5%) is dramatically lower than last year and is well below the historic norm of 21.2%.Busting the Myth About a Housing Affordability Crisis | MyKCM

2. Black Knight’s Mortgage Monitor:

This report reveals that as a result of falling interest rates and slowing home price appreciation, affordability is the best it has been in 18 months. Black Knight Data & Analytics President Ben Graboske explains:

“For much of the past year and a half, affordability pressures have put a damper on home price appreciation. Indeed, the rate of annual home price growth has declined for 15 consecutive months. More recently, declining 30-year fixed interest rates have helped to ease some of those pressures, improving the affordability outlook considerably…And despite the average home price rising by more than $12K since November, today’s lower fixed interest rates have worked out to a $108 lower monthly payment…Lower rates have also increased the buying power for prospective homebuyers looking to purchase the average-priced home by the equivalent of 15%.”

3. First American’s Real House Price Index:

While affordability has increased recently, Mark Fleming, First American’s Chief Economist explains:

“If the 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage declines just a fraction more, consumer house-buying power would reach its highest level in almost 20 years.”

Fleming goes on to say that the gains in affordability are about mortgage rates and the increase in family incomes:

“Average nominal household incomes are nearly 57 percent higher today than in January 2000. Record income levels combined with mortgage rates near historic lows mean consumer house-buying power is more than 150 percent greater today than it was in January 2000.”

Bottom Line

If you’ve put off the purchase of a first home or a move-up home because of affordability concerns, you should take another look at your ability to purchase in today’s market. You may be pleasantly surprised!  For a friendly conversation and advice just give me a call at 330-352-9513 or email 


Tony Morganti, CRS, ABR


Comment balloon 1 commentTony Morganti • August 15 2019 02:40PM
Busting the Myth About a Housing Affordability Crisis
It seems you can’t find a headline with the term “housing affordability” without the word “crisis” attached to it. That’s because some only consider the fact that residential real estate prices have continued to appreciate. However, we must realize… more
Rent Vs. Own
Owning your own home vs. renting may lead to some great options, such as locking in your monthly payments and having the freedom to customize your living space. Whether you rent or own, you have to cover someone’s mortgage costs. You may as well… more
How Much Do You Know About Down Payments?
Whether you’ve owned a home before, or you’re ready to jump into homeownership for the first time, there are always a lot of questions swirling around about what is truly required for a down payment, and how to best source down payment assistance… more
Just Sold in Cuyahoga Falls - 216 Birchwood Avenue
It took a few days but we were able to bring the seller multiple offers on this nicely updated 3 bedroom cape cod in Cuyahoga Falls. This home features a full, waterproofed basement, near totally repainted interior, hardwood under first floor… more
Now "Sale Pending" in Hudson, Ohio - 7630 Brandywine Road
What a gorgeous home! Rustic and secluded on nearly 6 wooded acres complete with pond. Rustic stone and ceder exterior reminds one of a vacation lodge in a private wooded setting. Surrounded by majestic pines but with a wide open area towards… more
Now Under Contract in Cuyahoga Falls - 2869 10th Street
We're so happy to announce that we have been successful in finding a cash buyer for this spacious 4 bedroom, 2 full bath updated colonial cape in Cuyahoga Falls. How inviting is that front porch! This home is also located just a short walk to… more
How to Increase Your Equity Over the Next 5 Years
Many of the questions currently surrounding the real estate industry focus on home prices and where they are heading. The most recent Home Price Expectation Survey (HPES) helps target these projected answers. Here are the results from the Q2 2019… more
Existing Home Sales Point Toward a Good Time to Sell
Existing Home Sales dropped 1. 7% from May to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 5. 27 million in June. Low inventory levels are still a factor in the market. The current supply of homes for sale is at 4. 4 months, which is less than the… more
Just Sold in Cuyahoga Falls - 2024 Broad Blvd.
I was honored to represent the seller in the sale of this near totally updated Cuyahoga Falls cape cod home. Selling price $135, 000 Featuring 3 bedrooms, all new flooring and paint, all new appliances and a two car garage! Great value. When you… more
Why Now Is the Perfect Time to Sell Your House
As a homeowner, it’s always tempting to dream about the next big project you’re going to tackle. The possibilities are endless. Should I renovate? Should I refinance? Should I stay? Should I move? The list goes on and on. In today’s housing market,… more